Custom Ice Cream Cakes

Celebrate with a Custom Ice Cream Cake

Select from some of our most popular flavor combinations for your custom 6" or 8" cake. Call the store or stop by to see what sizes and flavors we currently have available, or build your own below with your favorite flavors and candies. 

Below are some of the most popular cake combinations: 

  • Coffee & Vanilla
  • Campfire Smores & Chocolate Chip
  • Coffee Oreo & Vanilla
  • Maine Black Bear & Chocolate Chip
  • Black Raspberry & Vanilla
  • Green Monster & Death by Chocolate
  • Peanut Butter Oreo & Chocolate
  • Chocolate & Vanilla
  • Death by Chocolate & Chocolate Chip
  • Milky Way & Totally Turtle
  • Green Monster & Chocolate
  • Peanut Butter Oreo & Vanilla Oreo
Custom Ice Cream Cake at Village Scoop
Custom Ice Cream Cake at Village Scoop
Custom Ice Cream Cake at Village Scoop
Custom Ice Cream Cakes in the case at Village Scoop
Custom Easter Ice Cream Cake from Village Scoop
Custom Christmas Ice Cream Cake at Village Scoop

Create a Custom Ice Cream Cake

We usually can have a custom cake order ready with a minimum 4 days notice, but please try to order as early as you can! 

You can select up to 2 choices of ice cream currently available. If the flavor you select below is out of stock we will call you to select a substitute. The middle layer traditionally has a crumbled Oreo Cookie & Hot Fudge Center. You can substitute the center filling if desired. Select your choices below.

All custom cakes require payment in full at the time of order. 

Village Scoop Logo - Light

Our Hours

Sunday
12 PM - 8 PM
Monday
12 PM - 8 PM
Tuesday
Closed
Wednesday
12 PM - 8 PM
Thursday
12 PM - 8 PM
Friday
12 PM - 8 PM
Saturday
12 PM - 8 PM

Our Location

286 York St, York, ME 03909

(207) 361-4013

Our Offerings

Custom Ice Cream Cakes Birthday Parties
Order Online

Please note that Village Scoop isn't an allergen-free establishment. Although we make every attempt to avoid cross contamination with allergens, it is not guaranteed. Please discuss any concerns you have with your scooper. Order at your own risk.

© 2025 Village Scoop Ice Cream
Website by Creare Web Solutions